Preventive Detention

May 27th, 2009 by Leonard Birdsong


Birdsong has heard a lot of talk during the last few days about “Preventive Detention.”  This has come in the wake of President Obama’s plans to close  the Guantanamo Bay prison facility where terror suspects have been held for the last  five years.  The administration has said that in closing the facility some prisoners will be sent to their home countries, others to maximum federal prisons  in the United States, and some will be held in “Preventive Detention.”  The Obama administration is supposedly working on rules for “Prevention Detention” of terror suspects.

Birdsong wonders how many of the pundits and opinion writers even know what “Preventive Detention” means.  Years ago when Birdsong was federal prosecutor in Washington, D.C. he had a few criminal cases where he sought  “Preventive Detention” of certain defendants.  Birdsong is not certain that we can fashion rules of such detention for terror suspects that will not violate due process.

“Preventive Detention” is usually categorized, in the criminal sense,  for non-capital  crimes as confinement imposed